I haven’t written about school lately, not for lack of topics. Some of the best stories, however, will have to wait until after I retire. In the meantime, most of the latest antics I’ve composed only in my brain, and then they ghost around in there and never quite materialize onto paper or the blog.
Today, though, a series of events converged into the perfect storm that, without the support of my colleagues, would have left me drowning in a sea of frustration.
The first strike of thunder started with a student complaining about having to watch the Veterans’ Day special program on the morning announcements. In one of my rare “call your kids from the neighbor’s house” voices, I informed him that men and women died so he could whine about sitting in a classroom watching a flat screen television, and I was certain the soldiers’ families would so appreciate knowing how much he honored their contributions.
Announcements over, I returned graded papers. Strike two. A student who submitted an assignment that did not follow the guidelines, was incomplete, and looked as if he’d written it in the back of a pickup truck traveling over a gravel road, had the audacity to “bow up” and yammer about the unfairness of it all.
So, I launched into my “come to Jesus” speech (I don’t refer to it as that to my students; after all, I teach in a public high school). Inevitably, every class, every year requires one of these. Twelve weeks into the school year, the bar’s higher than it was in August, and they’re feeling the pain of chin bruises. Some of them react by stretching, working smarter, and asking for help. Others, usually the members of the “exert minimal effort for maximum gain” club, start fashioning voodoo dolls that are sporting glasses and sensible shoes.
Eight out of twenty-one students in the class submitted the assignment. The others “forgot” (note: each student was given a planner at the beginni
ng of the school year) because “you didn’t tell us it was due.” One student told me she’s too busy to do homework and, after all, she has six other classes. I reminded her I had 143 other students, and we all have the same twenty-four hours in a day.
Another informed me that I grade too hard. Not a surprise. In fact, just a few days ago, another teacher overheard a student say, “Mrs. Allan grades like a Nazi.” I didn’t know the Nazis had time to grade papers…but, anyway…I’ll own that I have high expectations. I don’t apologize for expecting more of them than they do of themselves because even if they fall short of what I expect, they’re often miles ahead of where they would have been. If they can’t meet some of my expectations–rigorous ones like writing in blue or black ink only, using a heading that includes writing a last name, not Joe T., and writing on the front of the paper–how’s that mindset going to work for them in the real world, with real jobs?
A student remarked, “I’m not going to need a job. I’m gonna be rich.” To which one of her classmates responded, “You can’t even pass English I, how you gonna get rich?” (I love when kids “get it”!)
Sure, they’re freshmen, and they’re young and silly and hormonal. I get that. But I’m not buying into the, “they’re ONLY freshmen” excuse for why they shouldn’t be held accountable or why they shouldn’t learn to self-advocate.
Nothing disappoints me more than spending my time reading work that’s obviously completed at the last minute or blatantly disregards guidelines or is woefully incomplete. And, honestly, I feel a wee bit resentful taking time away from my family, my friends, whatever…to spend with half-hearted attempts. When I do sit down to grade, I don’t do it after a fight with my husband, or after opening that month’s bills, or after being awake for twenty-three hours. I give them my best effort. It’s what I believe I should do. But, as I pointed out to them this morning, they expect my best effort, but don’t submit theirs.
The bell rings and Mr. Bowed-Up walks straight to the principal to complain. No problem because the principal then walks straight to me to tell me his suggestion to the student was to schedule a conference. (Two years ago at my former school, a parent left messages on an administrator’s phone that she was calling the school board to ask that I be fired. That apparently didn’t work out for her.)
Second period happens to be my planning period, so I sit to check my school email. Thunderbolt three. I’m not going into too much detail here because this is a yet unresolved issue. I open an email from a parent with whom I already had a conference, and find a l-o-n-g diatribe consisting of biting sarcasm sprinkled with bits of character assassination. In terms of emails I’ve received since that became an accepted communication, I’d say this one ranks in the top five of the most vituperative. I refuse to even dignify it with a response.
Sometimes it’s difficult for parents to accept that they want academic success more than the kid wants it. And it’s more difficult yet when the parents are working harder than their student because sometimes that leads to smug kids who thinks parental units will fight their battles. At an Advanced Placement reading two years ago, a college professor told me more and more parents are calling their offices asking for their student’s grades, demanding extra credit be given, wanting grade changes…Of course, the college teachers find all this quite amusing, and refer to them as “helicopter parents” because they’re constantly hovering over their kids.
Ultimately, it comes down to this: my wise father always told me, “Christa, you can’t push a wet noodle.”
Storm over.




When I look back at the people who pushed me the most - my Mom, some of my teachers, certain bosses - I often remember several situations that were uncomfortable or that angered me. I wasn’t as receptive to the criticism or advice as I should have been.
As I have grown older and look back over my life, it was during those times when someone held the bar high and made me step outside of my comfort zone that shaped my personality and character the most.
Keep up the good work! Shoot for the moon even if you miss, you’ll land among the stars!
Comment by Renee — November 12, 2009 @ 2:07 pm
Kids these days… seriously.
I feel like there is a huge difference between my classmates from high school and kids today.
I’m in a graduate program with classmates who are TERRIBLE writers. I wonder how they’ve made it this far.
Keep challenging your students! Someone needs to.
Comment by Ashley Poche' — November 12, 2009 @ 6:21 pm
Mrs. Allan, your blog posts about your class(es) are by far my favorite!! I hope everything else has been going well for you! I’ve been tracking your book progress, and I’m really excited for you!
Comment by Samuel Congiundi — November 12, 2009 @ 6:22 pm
I don’t know how you do it, or why! This is my first year teaching 2-5 grade creative writing and boy is it…I have no words! Though for me, the parents that are sending emails are the ones that are involved and want to find out how to help their kids at home. Those emails, I like. Glad I don’t have other ones to deal with though some parents were very surprised at their 2nd and 3rd graders progress reports with Fs and Ds (while some got As and Bs.) Might I be a grading Nazi as well! Or actually requiring these little ones to be responsible for taking home, doing, and returning their assignments. Hopefully I’ll have them trained before they’re freshman ;)
Comment by Gina — November 12, 2009 @ 9:18 pm
You were the hardest teacher I ever had. I love you for it now. When I went to college and wrote my first paper, I asked my professor to look over it before I handed it in. He told me that I wrote very well and better than many of his seniors.
So, thank you.
Screw those kids, be a hard ass! Help them learn to write!
Comment by Veronica — November 15, 2009 @ 4:38 pm